2023
Comments
Crown Corporations in Canada
I am giving a talk at the School of Law, National University of Mongolia next week during their Fourth Annual Conference on Issues in Constitutional and Administrative Law, on the topic of state-owned enterprises. Here are my thoughts… Why Crown Corporations? Crown corporations are “structural heretics”, designed to function as commercial players but to achieve […] Read more
Comments
When Do Guidelines Bind? An Analytical Framework: Part 1
I have written a paper entitled, “How Binding are Binding Guidelines? An Analytical Framework” to be published later this year in Canadian Public Administration. You can access a pre-publication version here. I will be posting the paper in parts over the coming weeks. Here are the introductory sections: Guidelines play an important role in contemporary […] Read more
Comments
Reminder: Professor Joseph Heath on the Civil Service, Tuesday March 14 11.30 eastern
The next speaker in this year’s Administrative Law & Governance Colloquium will be Professor Joseph Heath (University of Toronto). Professor Heath will be discussing his book The Machinery of Government: Public Administration and the Liberal State (OUP, 2020): In political theory, the traditional model of state power was that elected officials make policy decisions which […] Read more
Comments
New Paper — The Autonomy of Administration
Last September I participated in a University of Toronto symposium on the career of Justice Rosalie Abella. The papers from the symposium are to be published in the University of Toronto Law Journal. A pre-publication version of my piece, “The Autonomy of Administration“, is now available for download on SSRN: Justice Rosalie Abella is closely […] Read more
Comments
The Prospects for Candour in Canada: Barriers to Disclosure
In previous posts (here and here) I have introduced the concept of the duty of candour in judicial review proceedings and described the centrality of the ‘record’ to judicial review of administrative action. In this post, I will consider several barriers to disclosure of relevant information which further limit the content of the record and […] Read more
Comments
Appearing via Zoom at the Supreme Court of Canada as an Intervener
In a recent interview with Yves Faguy for CBA/ABC National, the Chief Justice of Canada, Richard Wagner, was asked about the risk that courts would ‘backslide’ into old practices and give up some of the technological advances made during the COVID-19 pandemic: N: You co-chaired the Action Committee on Court Operations in Response to COVID-19, which […] Read more
Comments
Chat GPT and Legal Research: A Cautionary Tale
Paul Daly February 21, 2023
Like many others, I have enjoyed using the new Chat GPT tool. I thought it would be useful in making a start on a project I would like to conduct on administrative monetary penalties. I engaged in a chat with the tool, which clearly understood the core concepts, and, after some prodding, it generated a […] Read more
Comments
Reminder: Fisher & Shapiro on Administrative Agencies, Tuesday, February 21, 11.30
Paul Daly February 17, 2023
Join us next Tuesday on Zoom for the next in this year’s Administrative Law & Governance Colloquium, with Professors Liz Fisher and Sidney Shapiro, discussing their book, Administrative Competence: Reimagining Administrative Law (CUP, 2021): This book, by two of the world’s leading administrative law scholars, reimagines administrative law as the law of public administration by […] Read more
Comments
Administrative Agencies are a They, not an It
Paul Daly February 6, 2023
I am as guilty as any writer of referring to “an” administrative decision-maker, or “the Tribunal” or “the Regulator”. But, with apologies to Kenneth Shepsle, administrative agencies are a “they”, not an “it”. An administrative decision, be it an adjudicative decision or the adoption of a rule or policy, will typically be the product of […] Read more
Comments
Reminder: Margit Cohn on the Executive, 11.30 eastern time Tuesday, February 7 (on Zoom): Administrative Law and Governance Colloquium 2023, “The Legitimacy of the State”
Paul Daly February 3, 2023
The 2023 Administrative Law & Governance Colloquium 2023 gets underway next Tuesday, with Professor Margit Cohn, who will be discussing her important recent book, A Theory of the Executive Branch: Tension and Legality (OUP, 2021): The executive branch in Western democracies has been granted a virtually impossible task: expected to ‘imperially’ direct the life of […] Read more